Register | Login
CASECHECK CASECHECK
CaseCheck(tm) Case Reports
Below are our most recent case summaries of Scottish Courts case reports, Employment Appeal Tribunal Decisions, Employment Tribunal decisions and House of Lords decisions. Please use the links on the left to access the case reports case summaries by case type. The CaseChecktm Scottish Courts,  Employment Tribunal summaries and House of Lords summaries can also be searched using our case reports search facility. The case reports search facility is available to registered users.
 
Where possible we have linked our case summaries to the corresponding judgment on the Scottish Courts Website or Bailii

**All information pertaining to the Scottish Courts Judgements remains the subject of crown copyright but may be reproduced without formal permission or charge for personal or in-house use.

R A Dixon v Chief Constable of Strathclyde Police S/120872/2006 F596/61
Location: Case TypesEmployment    
Posted by: Fiona Davidson 28/08/2008 07:51

A colour-blind graduate whose application to join the police was turned down because he suffers from colour vision abnormality has won the right to claim sex discrimination at an employment tribunal.

Robin Dixon (26) has already lost a disability discrimination claim against Strathclyde Police because of his colour blindness.

But now, following a preliminary hearing, he has won the right to fight his case again, this time on the grounds of sex discrimination.

The Glasgow tribunal ruled that although his claim was timebarred, the matter should be allowed to proceed to a full hearing on the basis of justice and equity.

Mr Dixon will now join another applicant, Graeme McCullie (29), from Kilmarnock, who was also turned down by Strathclyde Police because he too is colour-blind. Both will now have their sex discrimination claims heard by the Glasgow tribunal at a later date.

Mr Dixon, from East Kilbride, only discovered after losing his disability discrimination claim that more males than females were affected by colour blindness and that he might be able to argue his case on the grounds of indirect sex discrimination.

But Strathclyde Police objected as he had failed to lodge his complaint within three months of the alleged discriminatory act. His recruitment application was rejected in November 2005 but he did not lodge his sex discrimination claim with the Glasgow tribunal office until October 2006.

Mr Dixon, from East Kilbride, told last month's hearing to determine whether his case should be allowed to proceed, that it should be permitted to go ahead in the interests of justice, as he had been unaware prior to October 2006 that he could claim sex discrimination.

Mr Dixon, from East Kilbride, said it was his life-long ambition to join the police. He is now working as a store manager in Dublin.

A previous tribunal hearing Mr Dixon's disability discrimination claim heard evidence that Chief Inspector Douglas Campbell told him he would have made a good police constable but his application would not be progressed, explaining there were concerns about not only his own health and safety but also that of other officers and the general public. He explained there were concerns as to the reliability and credibility of evidence, which would rely on Mr Dixon's ability to distinguish colours being called into question.

Following the preliminary hearing, employment judge Michael MacMillan concluded ''The judgment of the tribunal is that the application is subject to time bar in terms of section 76(1) of the Sex Discrimination Act 1976. Having heard parties' submissions on the matter, the tribunal has determined to exercise the discretion available to it under Section 76(5), and allow the matter to proceed to a full hearing, on the basis of justice and equity.''

The case is expected to be heard towards the end of the year.

Court: Employment Tribunal (UK)
Comments (1) Add Comment
Re: R A Dixon v Chief Constable of Strathclyde Police S/120872/2006 F596/61
By Anon on 31/07/2009 14:50
Is there a date set for the near future? I to have been rejected by Strathclyde Police Force for having the same colour vision defect.
Your name:
Title:
Comment:
Make my profile public:
Add Comment  Cancel  
Latest Jobs
Para-Legal, Aberdeen - An opportunity has arisen for a Paralegal in a well respected legal organisation in Aberdeen By Michael Page International (11/03/10) ... more

In House Litigation Lawyer, Edinburgh - Leading FS organisation is looking to appoint an in house litigation lawyer in Edinburgh to deal with arange of contentious work By Michael Page International (11/03/10) ... more

In-House Supply Chain, Aberdeen (AC09460) - International Oil and Gas Operator require a supply chain lawyer to join their dynamic team. You must possess previous supply chain experience from the oil and gas industry and this represents an excellent opportunity to progress. By Thorpe Molloy (04/03/10) ... more

Residential Property Solicitor, Aberdeen (AC09441) - Leading Aberdeen practice require an experienced residential property solicitor, ideally with a client following, to join their team. You must possess a strong background in residential property work, preferably in the Aberdeen area and there are excellent prospects on offer with this respected firm. By Thorpe Molloy (25/02/10) ... more

Oil and Gas Solicitor, Aberdeen (AC09444) - Leading national law firm currently require an additional oil and gas lawyer to operate from their Aberdeen office. You must possess previous upstream oil and gas experience and the role will involve working on a range of upstream oil and gas transactions for the firm’s extensive client base. Excellent long term career prospects on offer together with an attractive package. By Thorpe Molloy (25/02/10) ... more

Contentious Construction lawyer, Edinburgh - The role will involve all areas of contentious construction, and allow the successful candidate to become involved with business development and further client relationships. By Michael Page International (18/02/10) ... more

Interim In House Solicitor, Edinburgh - The role will involve all areas of investment management from assistance with product development and regulatory legal issues to general commercial legal drafting, negotiation and transactional work. By Michael Page International (11/02/10) ... more

Case Investigations Manager & Gateway Team Manager, Edinburgh - Scottish Legal Complaints Commission. We are looking for people with the vision, determination and drive to form a key part of our management team and lead our people, achieve objectives and play a central role in making a real impact for the people of Scotland. By Michael Page International (03/02/10) ... more

Employment Associate/Partner, Edinburgh - This is an excellent role for either a Senior Associate or a partner in an existing practice, covering both contentious and non contentious Employment matters, and potentially related issues. By Michael Page International (28/01/10) ... more

Commercial Property Solicitor, Aberdeen (AC09370) - Dynamic Aberdeen practice firm require a Commercial Property solicitor to supplement their existing team. By Thorpe Molloy (28/01/10) ... more

Show Articles Published:
Range From
Range From
 
CaseCheck Limited can be contacted at First Floor, George House, 36 North Hanover Street, Glasgow, G1 2AD, 0845 620 5664, info@casecheck.co.uk
CaseCheck(tm) is brought to you by CaseCheck Limited, Registered in Scotland No. SC325811.We take our job seriously and for this reason we respect your privacy, your data and the use you make of our site.   This work by CaseCheck Limited is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-Share Alike 2.5 UK: Scotland License Creative Commons License. Please take a moment to read our legal notices: Disclaimer/Copyright Notice, Terms and Conditions, Privacy Policy.
This content is made available by CaseCheck Limited under a Creative Commons Licence